Up To Code – Perspectives from the ABCD

Earning Self-Regulation Through Professionalism

Earning Self-Regulation Through Professionalism

By Edward Lee 

In early 2019, late on a Sunday night, I received a voicemail from an old friend, Brian Jackson. Brian and I had first met during the summer of 1993 while serving as U.S. Marine Corps lawyers in North Carolina. I was—and still am—a stickler for organization. My desk was always immaculate, with every file neatly arranged.  

Brian was the complete opposite. His desk looked as though a grenade had exploded on it. If you ever visit the Academy offices and peek into his office, you’ll see that not much has changed. Despite the apparent chaos, Brian always knew exactly where everything was. I’ve read articles suggesting that people with messy desks are geniuses—or at least smarter than those of us who prefer things organized. There may be some truth to that theory, although whenever Brian and I disagree or butt heads, I tend to think it’s complete nonsense. 

Before that, Brian had been unexpectedly promoted from counsel to the Actuarial Board for Counseling and Discipline (ABCD) to the Academy’s general counsel. He had been scrambling to find a new ABCD counsel when his wife suggested he call me. At that point in my career, I had stepped away from practicing law and was operating my own executive search firm, placing lawyers with leading law firms and companies across the United States and Asia. After listening to Brian’s voicemail, I assumed he wanted me to conduct a search for a new ABCD counsel and agreed to meet him at the Academy offices. 

At the meeting, I was surprised to learn that he wasn’t recruiting me to conduct a search—he was recruiting me to become the Academy’s next ABCD counsel. As Brian explained the ABCD complaint process, much of it felt familiar because the procedures and due process considerations were similar to the courts-martial and military administrative hearings I had worked on during my military career. As for the actuarial profession, however, I knew very little. In fact, I don’t think I had ever met anyone who introduced themselves as an actuary. Nevertheless, Brian’s enthusiasm for the work, his respect for actuaries, and his appreciation for the important role they play convinced me to join the Academy. 

A New Appreciation 

Now entering my eighth year as ABCD counsel, I have found working with actuaries, the dedicated members of the ABCD, and the Academy staff to be both professionally rewarding and personally enjoyable. It has been a privilege to play a small role in helping preserve the actuarial profession’s tradition of self-regulation. 

Over those years, I’ve also watched technology, particularly artificial intelligence, become an increasingly prominent part of both professional and everyday life. Like many people, I’ve become curious about what these tools can—and cannot—do. 

I’ve come to rely on ChatGPT for personal research. I’ve used it to plan vacations, compare state tax burdens while considering retirement, and even get advice on how to train my very sweet—but stubborn—dachshunds. Recently, out of curiosity, I asked ChatGPT a simple question: “Which U.S. professions are purely self-regulated?” 

Here is part of its response: 

“Very few professions in the United States are purely self-regulated. Most licensed professions are regulated by state governments through licensing boards, even if professional associations also impose ethical standards. 

Actuaries are the closest example. 

The actuarial profession is unusual because there is generally no state license required to call oneself an actuary or perform most actuarial work. Instead, the profession relies on: 

  • The U.S. Qualification Standards (USQS) 
  • The Code of Professional Conduct (Code) 
  • The Actuarial Standards Board (ASB)*  
  • The Actuarial Board for Counseling and Discipline (ABCD) 
  • Discipline imposed by professional organizations such as the American Academy of Actuaries, Society of Actuaries, Casualty Actuarial Society, Conference of Consulting Actuaries, and American Society of Pension Professionals & Actuaries.” 

*The ASB promulgates actuarial standards of practice (ASOPs).  

If ChatGPT is correct that actuaries are among the closest examples of a purely self-regulating profession in the United States, it is because generations of actuaries have worked diligently to make—and keep—it that way. 

The Work Behind Self-Regulation 

Tens of thousands of hours have been—and continue to be—devoted by Academy volunteers and staff to developing, maintaining, and improving the professionalism framework that guides actuaries in producing high-quality work for their clients and the public. This framework also helps preserve the profession’s ability to regulate itself through the judgment of experienced actuaries rather than relying primarily on government regulators who may not possess the same specialized expertise. 

The vast majority of actuaries will never interact with the ABCD as either a complainant or a subject actuary. Many, however, will use the ABCD’s confidential request for guidance process to better understand their professional obligations under the Code, the USQS, and the ASOPs. Regardless of an actuary’s personal involvement with the ABCD, I can confidently say that the profession is extremely fortunate to have dedicated volunteers who willingly accept the difficult responsibility of evaluating potential violations of the Code, protecting the profession’s reputation, and ultimately serving the public interest. 

Closer to Home 

When I joined the Academy in 2019, my daughter was midway through her freshman year of high school. She would occasionally ask about my work, and I would explain that most of what I did was confidential. What I could share was how impressed I was by actuaries’ commitment to professionalism, their high-quality work, and their sense of responsibility to the profession as a whole. Just as Brian’s respect for actuaries impressed me during our first conversation about the ABCD, my own respect for the profession eventually influenced my daughter. She intentionally chose to attend a university with a strong actuarial science program. She graduated this past summer having passed both the FM and P exams and is now working at an actuarial consulting firm where, as she happily tells me, she “loves her job.” 

A Reputation Earned 

Looking back, I feel fortunate to have played a small role in supporting a profession that takes professionalism so seriously. The actuarial profession has earned its reputation for effective self-regulation through the dedication of countless volunteers, the commitment of its practitioners, and a shared belief that serving the public interest comes first.  

If ChatGPT is correct that actuaries are among the closest examples of a purely self-regulating profession in the United States, it is because generations of actuaries have worked diligently to make—and keep—it that way. 


Edward Lee is the ABCD counsel.